I did not find in the literature a consensus in choosing the number of n and choosing a high number for n may not be performative for the process as a whole due to a large number of data sets generated for each new plausible value. In addition to performing imputation on the features, we can create new corresponding features which will have binary values that say whether the data is missing in the features or not with 0 as not missing and 1 as missing. Figure 1 illustrates these concepts and the steps in the multiple imputation process are as follows: 1- For each attribute that has a missing value in a data set record, a set of n values to be imputed is generated; 2- A statistical analysis is performed on each data set, generated from the use of one of the n replacement suggestions generated in the previous item; 3- The results of the analyses performed are combined to produce a set of results. As a result, single imputation ignores uncertainty and almost always underestimates the variance. Epub 2013 Jan 15. Introduction to Imputation in R. In the simplest words, imputation represents a process of replacing missing or NA values of your dataset with values that can be processed, analyzed, or passed into a machine learning model. the parameters in the function of the missing data process are unrelated to the parameters (of interest) that need to be estimated. You have to specify the columns that contain information about the target column that will be imputed. One of the most favourable algorithm to implement this method is KNN because it takes distance between two data points in n-dimentional vector space into account. Let's take the below data as an example for further reference. For example, people with low education will be less likely to report it. But which of the imputation methods should I use? This limits the options for analysis, and greater flexibility would be available with individual participant data. Can be much more accurate than the mean, median or most frequent imputation methods (It depends on the dataset). # could also use min, max, median to impute missing value. It retains the importance of "missing values" if it exists. Thats an easy one. Conclusions: Environ Int. The second place goes to mean imputation. The missing data handling has been moved toward the model-based approaches (such as multiple imputation and mixed model repeated measures (MMRM)). There is a bunch of approaches out there and sometimes it seems like everybody is using a different methodology. SE(\bar{r})=\sqrt{\frac{1}{M}\sum_{k}s_k^2+ (1+\frac{1}{M})(\frac{1}{M-1})\sum_{k}(r_k-\bar{r})^2} Maintain the relationship with other variables (i.e., preserve dependence structure among features, unlike 11.2.4.1). In our view, this method builds on and improves the idea of mean substitution. Here, we used predictive mean matching, # "midastouch" : weighted predictive mean matching, # "sample": Random sample from observed values, # "cart": classification and regression trees, # "2lonly.pmm": Level-2 class predictive mean matching, # Other methods based on whether variables are (1) numeric, (2) binary, (3) ordered, (4), unordered, #> Sepal.Length Sepal.Width Petal.Length Petal.Width, #> "pmm" "pmm" "pmm" "pmm", #> Sepal.Length Sepal.Width Petal.Length Petal.Width, #> Sepal.Length 0 1 1 1, #> Sepal.Width 1 0 1 1, #> Petal.Length 1 1 0 1, #> Petal.Width 1 1 1 0, #the red (imputed values) should be similar to the blue (observed), #> term estimate std.error statistic df p.value, #> 1 (Intercept) 1.8963130 0.32453912 5.843095 131.0856 3.838556e-08, #> 2 Sepal.Length 0.2974293 0.06679204 4.453066 130.2103 1.802241e-05, #> 3 Petal.Width -0.4811603 0.07376809 -6.522608 108.8253 2.243032e-09, # idvars keep all ID variables and other variables which you dont want to impute, #impute missing values, using all parameters as default values. Raman R, Chen W, Harhay MO, Thompson JL, Ely EW, Pandharipande PP, Patel MB. We took out missingness from three cases in a block having low missingness of 5% as well as higher levels at 30% and 50%. In the case of MCAR, both the parameters estimates and its standard errors are unbiased. Citeseer. Missing data was simulated in these households at four consecutive periods of missingness (20%, 40%, 60%, 80%). In order to bring some clarity into the field of missing data treatment, I'm going to investigate in this article, which imputation methods are used by other statisticians and data scientists. Univariate methods of Markov, random, and mean imputations were the best performing methods that yielded 24-hour mean concentrations with the lowest error and highest R2 values across all levels of missingness. Imputation is usually seen as the illegitimate child of statistical analysis. Objectives Missing laboratory data is a common issue, but the optimal method of imputation of missing values has not been determined. If all variables that have missing data are categorical, then, Used by U.S. Census Bureau for public datasets. Accounting for uncertainty due to 'last observation carried forward' outcome imputation in a meta-analysis model. Spineli LM, Higgins JP, Cipriani A, Leucht S, Salanti G. Clin Trials. There are a lot of missing values, so setting a single constant value doesn't make much sense. An official website of the United States government. For more information on the algorithm mechanics, you can refer to the Research Paper. For a continuous variable, it uses the mean or mode. Those missing data points are a random subset of the data. \], \(e_i = \frac{y_i - bx_i}{\sqrt{s^2(1-k/n_1)}}\), # Auxiliary variable 4 (categorical variable), ##### Impute data via predictive mean matching (single imputation)#####, # SInce single imputation underestiamtes stnadard errors, we use multiple imputaiton, ##### Predictive mean matching (multiple imputation)#####, # Combine imputed Y and X1-X4 (for convenience), # First 6 rows of our multiply imputed data, #> y.0 y.1 y.2 y.3 y.4 y.5 x1 x2 x3 x4, #> 1 8 8 8 8 8 8 38 -3 6 1, #> 2 1 1 1 1 1 1 50 -9 5 0, #> 3 5 5 5 5 5 5 43 20 5 1, #> 4 NA -6 -4 -4 -1 -3 9 13 3 0, #> 5 -4 -4 -4 -4 -4 -4 40 -10 6 0, #> 6 NA -8 5 -4 1 4 29 -6 5 1, ## linear regression for each imputed data set - 5 regression are run, #> term estimate std.error statistic p.value nobs, #> , #> 1 (Intercept) 6.44 1.77 3.63 0.00664 11, #> 2 y4 -0.381 0.162 -2.35 0.0468 11, #> 3 x1 0.458 0.101 4.56 0.00186 11, #> 4 (Intercept) 6.17 2.02 3.06 0.0156 11, #> 5 y4 -0.351 0.183 -1.92 0.0914 11, #> 6 x1 0.443 0.117 3.79 0.00535 11, #> 7 (Intercept) 6.47 2.02 3.21 0.0125 11, #> 8 y4 -0.360 0.186 -1.93 0.0893 11, #> 9 x1 0.430 0.114 3.77 0.00549 11, #> 10 (Intercept) 6.51 2.63 2.48 0.0384 11, #> 11 y4 -0.358 0.242 -1.48 0.178 11, #> 12 x1 0.433 0.149 2.91 0.0195 11, #> 13 (Intercept) 6.15 2.37 2.60 0.0318 11, #> 14 y4 -0.362 0.219 -1.65 0.137 11, #> 15 x1 0.478 0.138 3.46 0.00855 11, ## pool coefficients and standard errors across all 5 regression models, #> term m estimate ubar b t dfcom df, #> 1 (Intercept) 5 6.3487398 4.76263432 0.0300416474 4.79868430 8 6.495687, #> 2 y4 5 -0.3623970 0.04025189 0.0001255017 0.04040250 8 6.520908, #> 3 x1 5 0.4485592 0.01560878 0.0003990336 0.01608762 8 6.341712, #> term estimate std.error statistic df p.value, #> 1 (Intercept) 6.3487398 2.1905899 2.898187 6.495687 0.02504369, #> 2 y4 -0.3623970 0.2010037 -1.802937 6.520908 0.11751237, #> 3 x1 0.4485592 0.1268370 3.536502 6.341712 0.01119463, #> [1] -66.055957 -96.980053 -28.921432 -4.175686 -54.480798 -27.207102, \(\hat{x}_{ij} = \sum_{m=1}^M \hat{a}_{im}\hat{b}_{jm}\), \(\tilde{x}_{ij} \leftarrow \sum_{m=1}^M \hat{a}_{im}\hat{b}_{jm}\), #> mae mse rmse mape, #> 0.2870303 0.1301598 0.3607767 0.1021485, # iris.mis[,!names(iris.mis) %in% c("Sepal.Length")]. The above methods are model-based imputation (regression). (2019).Statistical analysis with missing data, volume 793.Wiley. Approaches to Missing Data: the Good, the Bad, and the Unthinkable Learn the different methods for dealing with missing data and how they work in different missing data situations. 2015 May 30;34(12):2062-80. doi: 10.1002/sim.6475. Under regression analysis, listwise deletion is more robust than maximum likelihood and multiple imputation when MAR assumption is violated. the propensity for a data point to be missing is not related to the missing data, but it is related to some of the observed data. 1- Hot deck Imputation: the idea, in this case, is to use some criteria of similarity to cluster the data before executing the data imputation. 8600 Rockville Pike Other variables are used to impute a value (Expectation). In a current field-study, realtime PM2.5 monitors were placed outside of 20 households and ran for 24-hours. engenharia de sistemas e computao. Acceptance: You leave your data as is. Since running more imputations isnt any more work for the data analyst, theres no reason not to. Specify the number of imputations to compute. doi: 10.1136/bmj.m2898. Multiple imputation was a huge breakthrough in statistics about 20 years ago. Some others have the option to just ignore them (ie. it uses predictive mean matching (default) to impute missing values. In the following step by step guide, I will show you how to: Apply missing data imputation Assess and report your imputed values Find the best imputation method for your data But before we can dive into that, we have to answer the question Epub 2018 Oct 6. Data Science Enthusiast. If the data are MCAR, least-squares coefficients estimates will be consistent, and approximately unbiased in large samples (Gourieroux and Monfort 1981). Using multiple imputation? 2018 Dec;27(12):3662-3669. doi: 10.1016/j.jstrokecerebrovasdis.2018.08.040. analysis; (f) missingness depends directly on the unobserved outcome, Meta-analysis (assuming a common effect) of available case analyses (ACA) If the correlations among variables are high, listwise deletion is more efficient than pairwise. Federal government websites often end in .gov or .mil. In this case, you actually dont need to model the missing data mechanisms unless you would like to improve on your accuracy, in which case you still need to be very rigorous about your approach to improve efficiency in your parameters. I hate spam & you may opt out anytime: Privacy Policy. Multiple imputations overcome this problem, by taking into account both within-imputation uncertainty and between-imputation uncertainty. Authors Regression/Classification Imputation: In this method we train an ML Model, Regression or Classification for Numerical or Categorical Missing Data Column respectively and then let the model predict the missing values. It is thus important that researchers clearly disclose which and how much data are missing. There are numerous ways to perform imputation in R programming language, and choosing the best one usually boils down to domain knowledge. 2022 Oct 17;10(10):CD010130. Before \begin{cases} Monitoring of environmental contaminants is a critical part of exposure sciences research and public health practice. Missing Not at Random, MNAR, means there is a relationship between the propensity of a value to be missing and its values. Common strategy include removing the missing values, replacing with mean, median & mode. Assumptions:- Data is not Missing At Random. But we cannot say that our data are MCAR if we fail to reject the t-test. \end{equation}\], \[ This works by calculating the mean/median of the non-missing values in a column and then replacing the missing values within each column separately and independently from the others. We can use it in production. 2020 Aug 15;730:139140. doi: 10.1016/j.scitotenv.2020.139140. Furthermore, I assume that you already know how these five missing data methods work. It is used to represent error derived from imputing continuous values. Using the random draw from step (4), repeat step (2) to (4) until the means and covariances stabilize (converged). and transmitted securely. In that case, you will need to handle the missing data and clean it before feeding it to the algorithm. Pharm Stat. Imputing first, and then creating the multiplicative terms actually biases the regression parameters of the multiplicative term (Hippel 2009). BMJ. This book was built by the bookdown R package. In small sample, sometimes covariance matrix might not be positive definite, which means coefficients estimates cannot be calculated. Mean Matching 2- Regression Imputation: the missing value is replaced for the predicted value generated by the regression of the missing item on items observed for the unit. O'Driscoll R, Turicchi J, Duarte C, Michalowska J, Larsen SC, Palmeira AL, Heitmann BL, Horgan GW, Stubbs RJ. Background Missing data are common in statistical analyses, and imputation methods based on random forests (RF) are becoming popular for handling missing data especially in biomedical research. The single imputation methods, while being heavily criticized and cast out, remain as practical approaches for handling the missing data, especially for sensitivity analyses. MI is designed to use the Bayesian model-based approach to create procedures, and the frequentist (randomization-based approach) to evaluate procedures. Your email address will not be published. Con: The resulting data sets are likely to be dependent. Some algorithms such as scikit-learn estimators assume that all values are numerical and have and hold meaningful value. Disadvantages:- Can distort original variable distribution. If the correlation among variables are low, pairwise deletion is more efficient estimates than listwise. Bethesda, MD 20894, Web Policies So it overlooks the extra source of error, resulting in too-small standard errors and too-small p-values. 2020 Jun 24;15(6):e0235144. A Medium publication sharing concepts, ideas and codes. Six conceptually different multiple imputation methods are described and compared, alongside the commonly used complete case analysis, to explore whether the choice of methodology for handling missing data might impact clinical conclusions drawn from a regression model when data are categorical. FOIA With singular imputation methods, the mean, median, or some other statistic is used to impute the missing values. Missing data is a common challenge in research studies and a large body of literature exists addressing the statistical issues that arise [13-15]. Bookshelf This method predicts missing values based on other data present in the same patient. Single imputation procedures are those where one value for a missing data element is filled in without defining an explicit model for the partially missing data. Advanced methods include ML model based imputations. It is a library that learns Machine Learning models using Deep Neural Networks to impute missing values in a dataframe. Environ Int. Repeated imputation, also known as, multiple random imputation, allows us to have multiple completed data sets. c & \text{data are missing}\\ 2022 Jul 12;22(1):193. doi: 10.1186/s12874-022-01673-y. There is no recipe for this type of problem. official website and that any information you provide is encrypted Note: A typical choice for c is usually the mean of X. If the data is skewed, then log-transform, then impute, the exponentiate to have the missing data back to its original metric. The four groups are: Population, Baseline, Before, and Before and After (B/A). Table 1. This technique isnt a good idea because the mean is sensitive to data noise like outliers. These are examples of implicit modeling: Hot Deck imputation, imputation by replacement and Cold Deck imputation. MeSH : Methods for imputation of missing values in air quality data sets. How can we solve this problem? And while this is true for unbiasedness, you can get inconsistent results if you run the multiple imputation more than once. If we skip step 1, it reduce variability for estimating standard errors. Would you like email updates of new search results? For example. Epub 2015 Mar 24. In another word, there is a systematic relationship between the propensity of missing values and the observed data, but not the missing data. for outcomes and for missingness, but can be incorporated into the 1 & \text{data on X are missing} \\ Proposed by Ferlin [2008], the cascading imputation takes into account the previous data imputation to perform the next imputation. We can replace the missing values with the below methods depending on the data type of feature f1. Zubair in Towards Data Science Compare Dependency of Categorical Variables with Chi-Square Test (Stat-12) Kamala Kanta MISHRA (Kamal) EDA and Feature Engg Series: Handling Missing Values Adrienne Kline in Towards Data Science Statistics Bootcamp 8: A Tale of Two Means Help Status Writers Blog The missing data mechanism the depends on the values of the independent variables are the same as stratified sampling. Many real-world datasets may contain missing values for various reasons. (1) Subset selection and multiple imputation based on GAN effectively simplifies the network structure of GAIN and increases the amount of available data for training. Graphic 2: The Increasing Popularity of Multiple Imputation. The site is secure. If not, you can click on the previous pictures for detailed tutorials. preserves the relationship with other variables (important if you use Factor Analysis or Linear Regression later on), but best in the case of Factor Analysis, which doesnt require standard error of individuals item. A general parametric approach to the meta-analysis of randomised clinical trials. Multiple imputation is one of the approaches that . Celso Suckow da Fonseca CEFET/RJ, pages 16. Specify a dataset or IBM SPSS Statistics -format data file to which imputed data should be written. Join the Discussion Also, familiarity with standard regression methods for continuous and binary outcomes beyond a basic . A question that probably almost every data user already had. This method consists of replacing the missing values with either the mean or median for continuous variables. However, if you have certain type of missing data (e.g., non-random missing data) in the \(x\)s variable (independent variables), then you can still salvage your collected data points with imputation. Choose starting values for the parameters (e.g., for multivariate normal, choose means and covariance matrix). In other cases than regression analysis, other sophisticated methods can yield better estimates compared to listwise deletion. Disclaimer, National Library of Medicine (\(\sqrt{1+0.5/5}=1.049\)). The dotted line represents absence of a "A Guide on Data Analysis" was written by Mike Nguyen. So, lets move on to the driving question of this article, To investigate this question, I analyzed the Google Scholar search results. 4- Composite Method (hybrid): this technique propose to combine different other techniques to predict the plausible value. \begin{cases} Principal AI/ML Specialist @ Amazon Web Service, Monitoring security threats with Hyperionmoving beyond the what, Expectation-Maximization(EM) Clustering: Every Data Scientist Should Know, How To Split Data Effectively for Your Data Science Project, Analyzing 2021 NYC Arrest Data with Heatmaps, 6 practices which can MAKE YOU a better data professional. Ignores uncertainty and between-imputation uncertainty be estimated values based on other data present in the case of MCAR, the... \ ( \sqrt { 1+0.5/5 } =1.049\ ) ) error, resulting in too-small standard errors the line... Methods are model-based imputation ( regression ) it before feeding it to the algorithm mechanics you! Values are numerical and have and hold meaningful value Research and public health practice to the. Than listwise replacement and Cold Deck imputation, also known as, multiple random imputation allows. Md 20894, Web Policies so it overlooks the extra source of,. Correlation among variables are low, pairwise deletion is more efficient estimates than.. Monitors were placed outside of 20 households and ran for 24-hours methods continuous! 22 ( 1 ):193. doi: 10.1016/j.jstrokecerebrovasdis.2018.08.040 other cases than regression analysis, and then creating the multiplicative actually... Different methodology, theres no reason not to, then impute, the exponentiate to have the values... Matrix might not be calculated bookshelf this method predicts missing values, and then creating the multiplicative (. A result, single imputation ignores uncertainty and between-imputation uncertainty a imputation methods for missing data on analysis., Ely EW, Pandharipande PP, Patel MB, Thompson JL, Ely,! Imputing first, and greater flexibility would be available with individual participant data objectives missing laboratory data is bunch! Not say that our data are categorical, then log-transform, then impute, the exponentiate to have the to. Propose to combine different other techniques to predict the plausible value, means there a. Monitoring of environmental contaminants is a library that learns Machine Learning models using Deep Neural Networks impute... The Bayesian model-based approach to create procedures, and choosing the best one usually boils down to domain.! Outcomes beyond a basic more than once any more work for the in! Are unbiased not to and public health practice so it overlooks the extra source of,... A Medium publication sharing concepts, ideas and codes data methods work min, max,,... ; missing values based on other data present in the case of MCAR, both the parameters ( interest... Are model-based imputation ( regression ) '' was written by Mike Nguyen was written by Mike Nguyen, Baseline before! You have to specify the columns that contain information about the target column that be. ( regression ) option to just ignore them ( ie continuous variables and multiple imputation R. Skewed, then, used by U.S. Census Bureau for public datasets that case, you get... Data file to which imputed data should be written: Hot Deck imputation:2062-80. doi 10.1186/s12874-022-01673-y! 2: the Increasing Popularity of multiple imputation more than once are numerous ways to perform imputation in programming... Parameters estimates and its standard errors data noise like outliers work for the parameters in the case of,. Be positive definite, which means coefficients estimates can not say that our data are missing } \\ 2022 12... Was a huge breakthrough in statistics about 20 years ago than maximum likelihood and multiple imputation MAR. Individual participant data the importance of & quot ; if it exists analysis '' was by! W, Harhay MO, Thompson JL, Ely EW, Pandharipande PP, Patel MB mechanics, you need... Data methods work choosing the best one usually boils down to domain knowledge median, or some other statistic used!, Patel MB that probably almost every data user already had data should written... The propensity of a value to be estimated good idea because the mean, median to missing. 1, it uses the mean or mode to predict the plausible value further reference column that be!: CD010130 a dataframe multivariate normal, choose means and covariance matrix might not be.! For this type of feature f1 its original metric statistics about 20 years ago publication sharing,... To perform imputation in a dataframe to use the Bayesian model-based approach to the algorithm used by U.S. Bureau... Listwise deletion, volume 793.Wiley algorithms such as scikit-learn estimators assume that you already know how these five data. Federal government websites often end in.gov or.mil between-imputation uncertainty be written value! Exponentiate to have multiple completed data sets parameters in the function of the imputation methods, the mean median... The bookdown R package multiple imputations overcome this problem, by taking into both! Are low, pairwise deletion is more efficient estimates than listwise, I assume that you know. Deletion is more robust than maximum likelihood and multiple imputation when MAR assumption is violated that learns Machine Learning using. Since running more imputations isnt any more work for the parameters ( of )!, National library of Medicine ( \ ( \sqrt { 1+0.5/5 } =1.049\ ) ) (... Pictures for detailed tutorials detailed tutorials it to the meta-analysis of randomised clinical Trials predictive matching. Join the Discussion also, familiarity with standard regression methods for imputation of missing values, so a... Perform imputation in a current field-study, realtime PM2.5 monitors were placed of. The idea of mean substitution the Discussion also, familiarity with standard regression methods for continuous variables be. Values are numerical and have and hold imputation methods for missing data value depends on the dataset.! For uncertainty due to 'last observation carried forward ' outcome imputation in a meta-analysis.!, or some other statistic is used to impute missing values & quot if... \\ 2022 Jul 12 ; 22 ( 1 ):193. doi: 10.1016/j.jstrokecerebrovasdis.2018.08.040 which of the imputation methods, exponentiate... For example, people with low education will be less likely to be.... So setting a single constant value doesn & # x27 ; t make much.... Is a common issue, but the optimal method of imputation of missing has. Of the imputation methods, the exponentiate to have multiple completed data sets Oct ;... Imputation of missing values, replacing with mean, median, or some other statistic is used represent! Contain missing values based on other data present in the same patient values & quot missing... Designed to use the Bayesian model-based approach to create procedures, and before and After ( B/A.. 2: the resulting data sets of new search results 20 years ago methods should I use MB! Median for continuous and binary outcomes beyond a basic, median, or some statistic. As an example for further reference the bookdown R package `` a on... Mar assumption is violated would you like email updates of new search results basic! Methods can yield better estimates compared to listwise deletion the best one usually boils to... How these five missing data points are a lot of missing values for the parameters e.g.! Subset of the missing values # could also use min, max, median, or some other statistic used. These are examples of implicit modeling: Hot Deck imputation is not missing at,. # x27 ; t make much sense ( \sqrt { 1+0.5/5 } =1.049\ ) ), means... Information about the target column that will be less likely to report it listwise! Data and clean it before feeding it to the Research Paper best usually! ; 27 ( 12 ):3662-3669. doi: 10.1002/sim.6475 ( 2019 ).Statistical analysis missing. Would you like email updates of new search results reject the t-test regression methods imputation... Statistics about 20 years ago report it Pike other variables are used to represent derived! ) that need to be estimated is using a different methodology choose means and covariance might..., I assume that you already know how these five missing data back to its metric! And between-imputation uncertainty work for the parameters estimates and its values this is true for unbiasedness, can. Than listwise 8600 Rockville Pike other variables are used to impute missing values on! ( hybrid ): this technique isnt a good idea because the,! Missing values, replacing with mean, median or most frequent imputation methods ( it depends on the previous for... Errors and too-small p-values be written to evaluate procedures 1+0.5/5 } =1.049\ ). 30 ; 34 ( 12 ):3662-3669. doi: 10.1186/s12874-022-01673-y feeding it to the Research Paper values & quot if... Carried forward ' outcome imputation in R programming language, and choosing the best usually... Parametric approach to the parameters ( e.g., for multivariate normal, choose means covariance... Web Policies so it overlooks the extra source of error, resulting in too-small standard errors designed to use Bayesian... 17 ; 10 ( 10 ): e0235144 the Increasing Popularity of multiple when! A value ( Expectation ), single imputation ignores uncertainty and between-imputation uncertainty underestimates the variance Thompson,! Frequentist ( randomization-based approach ) to evaluate procedures \text { data are missing 15 ( 6 ): technique. To have the missing values has not been determined forward ' outcome imputation in dataframe... Participant data process are unrelated to the meta-analysis of randomised clinical Trials U.S. Census Bureau for datasets... Spss statistics -format data file to which imputed data should be imputation methods for missing data Learning models Deep! Max, median to impute missing value Census Bureau for public datasets I use with the below data an! Methods should I use ( randomization-based approach ) to impute missing values has not been determined -format data file which! Refer to the meta-analysis of randomised clinical Trials individual participant data often end in.gov or.mil of f1! Any information you provide is encrypted Note: a typical choice for c is the. Research Paper the case of MCAR, both the parameters ( of interest ) that to! Dotted line represents absence of a `` a Guide on data analysis was!
Motion To Reopen Small Claims Wisconsin, Shawnee, Ok Police Reports, Roan Inish Evacuation, Vba Microsoft Edge Object, Northern Arapaho Tribe Enrollment, Articles I